February 27th, 2011 22:34 EST
True, 'We Belong Together,' But the Oscar for Original Song Goes to 'If I Rise!'
Four excellent choices to pick from for tonight`s Oscar in the Original Song category. I purchased all four nominees on iTunes this afternoon so I could run my own little contest. The winner was fairly obvious to me after repeated listening.
I must make a startling confession, I haven`t seen any of these films so far. But it is possible, I believe, to judge the songs on their own merits, without seeing the films (I can see, also, where this might be incorrect). It doesn`t really matter, fellow, here`s my choices in the order of favorites:
1. IF I RISE 127 HOURS
I hope this one wins tonight. What makes this New Agy one work so well is A.R. Rahman`s recurring riff on the harpejji, an electric string instrument that was just invented in 2007. And Dido`s vocals sound as if they were sung from Mount Everest or even higher, like heaven itself.
Without having seen this remarkable film (I`ve heard), I`m anxious to see the placement of the song within the plot. The Gleehive Children`s choir from Mumbai is another pleasant touch to If I Rise. A partnership of A.R. Rahman and Danny Boyle is like Nina Rota and Federico Fellini, a marriage made in heaven between filmmaker and sound track composer. If it don`t win I just may kick this brown-brick linoleum tile in my microscopic condo!
2. I SEE THE LIGHT TANGLED
So beautiful, it will probably get the Oscar tonight. This fairy tale love song, with music by Alan Menken and lyrics by Glenn Slater, has the weight of Western culture behind it, or rather the Germanic oomph of Rapunzel and The Brothers Grimm, who rule with an iron fist the nether-fantasy world of frogs and princes, climbing golden locks of hair up spiraling gossamer towers of confinement.
Alan Menken is aiming for a Medieval dream trip here and it works immaculately well. Disney-esque vocals provided by Mandy Moore and Zachary Levi keep your head in cumulous clouds while you`re flying to Memphis on business. No, make that Cleveland! Make that a vacation, while you`re at it!
3. WE BELONG TOGETHER TOY STORY 3
Another catchy one from Randy Newman, doing the honors with music, lyrics and performance. I wouldn`t say it`s his all-time best, almost out of a mold, but the pacing is irresistible. The horn and rhythm sections make it for me; trots down the road like an early Van Morrison tune.
Randy Newman is a master craftsman of pop songs, and We Belong Together is no exception to that clichÃ© stated with mediocrity. No Short People, but strong RN nevertheless! *(Footnote is no one can come close, when it comes to writing Bridges.)
4. COMING HOME COUNTRY STRONG
This is not a bad country song, written by Jennifer Hanson, Tony Martin and Mark Nesler, with the glamorous actress Gwyneth Paltrow as the artist grasping the microphone. The production factor is a tad bit rich and the lyrics a trifle Everyman as a euphemism for generic. I was digging the ditty up to the point where it has a double key change with Gwyny shattering expensive crystal to grab the pitch of DollyLand rhapsody. Coming Home got nominated, so what do I know.
I feel comfortable with any of these four songs. Yet, If I Rise transcends the other three for feel and original instrumentation. I get an ineffable touch of hope when listening. The theme of survival through spirituality is what transfers through my ears.
Maybe Dido will sing it tonight. 127 Hours is not currently showing in Austin. That`s alright, I will buy the Blu-Ray anyhow! I`ll see you on the Red Carpet, okay, make that the red-brick linoleum tile.